Super Bowl Betting Secrets: Fun Facts You Need to Know! Updated for September 2025

09/02/2025 | Categories: NFL | Published by: Andy Nelson

Updated: 22nd September 2025

Every year, millions of dollars are wagered on the Super Bowl, making it the biggest sports betting event in the U.S. But did you know that some of the most popular bets have surprising trends, hidden patterns, and even a little superstition involved? Whether you're betting big or just placing a friendly wager, knowing these Super Bowl betting secrets and fun facts could give you an edge—or at least make the game more exciting!

1. The Coin Toss Bet—Is It Really 50/50?

One of the most popular Super Bowl bets has nothing to do with the actual game—it’s the coin toss!

📌 Fun Fact: The team that wins the coin toss has lost 9 straight Super Bowls (as of 2024). Coincidence? Maybe. But bettors have started paying attention!

📌 Heads vs. Tails: Historically, tails has come up slightly more often than heads (leading 29-28 in Super Bowl history). But every flip is still a true 50/50 shot.

Did you know that the coin toss isn't always just luck? While it's true that every flip is a 50/50 shot, there have been curious shifts in outcomes.

From 2014 to 2018, the team that won the toss also went on to win the game. These small trends, while not foolproof, captivate bettors every year!

If you’re looking for a quick, exciting bet, this one pays out before the game even starts!

2. The “White Jersey” Super Bowl Curse (or Luck?)

Does jersey color matter? History says YES!

🔹 Teams wearing white jerseys have won 16 of the last 20 Super Bowls
🔹 The Chiefs will wear white in Super Bowl LIX, while the Eagles will wear green

Why do white jerseys seem so lucky? Some believe it's more than just superstition, pointing to the contrast in visibility or historical team choices.

Interestingly, teams wearing white have won seven of the last 10 games. Could this be more than just chance? Bettors think so!

Why does this trend exist? No one knows for sure, but bettors often factor this into their decisions!

3. Underdogs vs. Favorites—Who Actually Wins?

Everyone loves an underdog story, but do they actually win? Here’s what the stats say:

✅ Favorites are 37-21 straight up (winning outright) in Super Bowl history
✅ But underdogs have covered the spread in 9 of the last 13 Super Bowls
✅ Since 2007, underdogs have won the Super Bowl outright 7 times!

If you're betting against the spread (ATS), underdogs have been a solid play in recent years.

Betting on Over/Under Totals

When it comes to over/under, there's a pattern you can't ignore. In the past decade, the ‘under' has hit six times, leaving many bettors thrilled.

Games can be unpredictable, but stats show Super Bowl defenses can rise to the occasion, keeping scores low compared to expectations.

4. First Touchdown Scorer—Watch the Tight Ends!

One of the most exciting bets you can place is who will score the first touchdown. Here’s a little secret:

📌 In the last 10 Super Bowls, tight ends have scored the first TD 4 times
📌 Travis Kelce (Chiefs) and Dallas Goedert (Eagles) are prime candidates this year

Certain players seem to have a knack for scoring early. In recent Super Bowls, Tom Brady and Rob Gronkowski have been famous for connecting on first touchdowns.

This opens the door for tight end bets, especially with history favoring them in these key moments.

If you want higher odds and a bigger payout, betting on a tight end instead of a wide receiver or running back could be the move!

5. Gatorade Color—A Bet Based on Superstition?

One of the weirdest but most fun Super Bowl bets is predicting the color of the Gatorade poured on the winning coach.

Here’s what history tells us:

🎨 Orange: Most common, used 5 times since 2001
🎨 Blue: Used 4 times since 2015 (including last year)
🎨 Clear/Water: Randomly appeared in 2005 & 2014
🎨 Purple: Used in 2020 (when the Chiefs last won!)

Insider tip: Some bettors watch pre-game sideline coolers to see what color drinks players are using!

6. Super Bowl MVP—Quarterbacks Dominate, But…

Everyone assumes the Super Bowl MVP will be the winning quarterback, and they’re usually right:

🏆 31 of 58 Super Bowl MVPs have been QBs (over 50%!)
🏆 But wide receivers have won 4 of the last 9 MVPs
🏆 The last defensive MVP was Von Miller in 2016

If you’re looking for value bets, consider picking a star wide receiver or a game-changing defensive player instead of just the quarterback.

7. National Anthem & Halftime Show Bets—The Most Random Fun You Can Have

Super Bowl Merchandise Sales and Betting

Super Bowl merchandise sales often hint at betting favorites. When teams like the Patriots or Cowboys take the field, their fan base shows strong support through gear purchases.

This goes hand in hand with betting volume, where popular teams see higher stakes placed on them. Records show such sales soar, telling us exactly where loyal fans place their faith.

Super Bowl betting isn’t just about football. You can bet on off-the-wall things like:

🎤 How long will the National Anthem last? (Average is 1 minute, 56 seconds)
🎤 Will the singer forget or mess up a word?
🎵 What will the first song of the halftime show be? (Kendrick Lamar is this year’s performer!)

If you’re looking for fun, silly bets that have nothing to do with football, these are for you!

8. BetNow’s $500,000 Super Bowl Scratch & Win! 🎉

Want to win big without even making a bet? BetNow’s $500,000 Scratch & Win promotion is giving players a shot at massive prizes!

Here’s how it works:
✅ Deposit anytime during Super Bowl Week
✅ Get a scratch card the next day
✅ Win your share of $500,000 in prizes!

Every deposit gives you more chances to win, making this the perfect way to add even more excitement to Super Bowl week!

👉 Visit bnlive.tv/scratch to play!

Final Thoughts: Super Bowl Betting Is More Than Just the Game!

Super Bowl LIX is shaping up to be an unforgettable showdown, and betting on it can make the game even more thrilling. Whether you’re playing it safe with traditional bets or trying your luck with fun prop bets, knowing these betting secrets and trends can help you make smarter picks!

So, will the Chiefs go back-to-back, or will the Eagles finally get their revenge? No matter the outcome, this year’s Super Bowl is going to be one for the history books! 🏆🏈